What Happens If a Tree Falls on Your Neighbor’s House in Oklahoma City?

On a windy Saturday in northwest Oklahoma City, Kyle was watching the weather radar while sipping his coffee. A strong storm was blowing through, but his yard had weathered worse. That was, until a loud crack rang out from the back of the house. One of his old oak trees had toppled over—right onto his neighbor’s roof.

The next morning brought more than cleanup. There were questions from the neighbor. Then from the neighbor’s insurance company. Then from Kyle’s own agent.

So here’s the big question: If your tree falls on your neighbor’s house, whose insurance pays?
​
Let’s break it down.

need better home insurance for your okc house?

It Depends on Why the Tree Fell

Insurance companies don’t just look at what happened—they look at why it happened. Was it an act of nature, or neglect?

If It Fell Due to a Storm or Wind

In most cases, if the tree was healthy and simply got knocked over by wind or lightning, your neighbor’s own insurance covers the damage to their home.

Even though it was your tree, it wasn’t your fault. Insurance views this as “no-fault,” meaning each homeowner handles their own repairs.

If It Fell Due to Neglect

If the tree was clearly dead, leaning, diseased, or already at risk—and you did nothing to remove it--you may be held liable.

In this case, your neighbor’s insurance may still pay for emergency repairs, but they might come after your insurance to recoup costs.
This is where your liability coverage in your homeowners policy comes into play.

Will Your Home Insurance Pay If You're at Fault?

If you’re found negligent, your homeowners policy may help cover:

• Damage to your neighbor’s home
  
• Legal defense if you’re sued
  
• Settlement costs, up to your liability limits
  

But if you’re not at fault (e.g., wind pushed over a healthy tree), then typically:

• Your policy doesn’t cover your neighbor’s damage
  
• Their policy handles their repairs
  
• You’re not responsible financially
  

What About Removing the Tree?

Here’s where it gets tricky. Most policies separate removal costs from damage costs.
For Your NeighborIf your tree damages their house, their insurance might cover tree removal, but only for the portion that actually hit the house.
​
If the rest of the tree is just lying in the yard? They might be stuck with that bill unless they have additional coverage for debris removal.

For YouIf your tree falls but doesn’t hit anything—not even your own property--you might be fully responsible for removing it out-of-pocket.

Real Oklahoma City Scenarios Where This Comes Up

A 45 mph gust blows over a healthy tree onto your neighbor’s fence. This is considered an “act of God.” Their policy covers repairs.
​
Scenario 2: Diseased Tree You IgnoredYour tree was clearly dying for years. Your neighbor warned you about it. After a mild storm, it topples and caves in part of their roof. Your liability coverage may be on the hook.

Scenario 3: It Falls on a Shared Property LineIf it lands on both properties, both policies may split the damage—or your neighbor may file under theirs, and their insurance might subrogate (go after your insurer) if fault is found.

How to Protect Yourself Before a Tree Ever Falls

Oklahoma weather is unpredictable, but proper tree care goes a long way. Here’s what you can do:

• Schedule yearly tree inspections
  
• Remove dead or leaning trees
  
• Trim branches that hang over roofs or fences
  
• Document warnings or tree concerns from neighbors
  

This can show that you’re not negligent—and may help avoid a future claim denial or lawsuit.

Do You Have Enough Liability Coverage?

Most standard home insurance policies include $100,000 to $300,000 in personal liability coverage. But if your assets, income, or exposure are higher, you might want more.
​
Ask about an umbrella policy—it can provide an extra layer of protection if a court finds you at fault for serious damage or injury.

When a Tree Falls, Will You Be Ready?

Storms happen. Trees fall. And neighbors talk.
​
At Oklahoma Insurance Professionals, we help homeowners across the OKC area—from Edmond to Moore, Norman to Midwest City—understand what their home insurance actually covers.

We’re an independent insurance agency based right here in Oklahoma City, which means we work for you—not a big carrier. Whether you’re worried about trees, fences, or flying shingles, we’ll help you find the right protection for your property, your wallet, and your peace of mind.

Need to review your coverage or upgrade your liability limits?

Reach out today for a free homeowners insurance quote—we’ve got your back.

get the best okc home insurance!

---

Scott Godwin
Founder

Oklahoma Insurance Professionals LLC serves Oklahoma City and the surrounding Oklahoma communities by protecting the people we work with just like we protect our own family members. Home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, and more. We can help you find the coverage you need. ​